The Heroes Round Table

The H2 phoenix is well-drawn, and fills up the available pixels, which helps to make it more impressive (important when it's squeezed into the same size square as an orc). But the shimmering, cycling, distracting feathers... so...shiny...must...stare...AAAAUGH it burns us!

H1 is the most elegant, so it gets my vote. Somehow I think a phoenix should look as if it would be at home on a jewel-encrusted perch.
I agree with earlier posts. H4=Giant Chicken of Doom

H3 war unicorn, hands down, with H5 silver unicorn a close second (although I don't own H5, so I don't have the animations to sway me). As for the H4 unicorn, I have two words: Lisa Frank. (Google it and ask for Markie the unicorn, and you'll see what I mean...)